
John W. Martin: “The Fall of Nineveh,” 1829Source: Friends of Art Endowment Fund
“Lo, all our pomp of yesterday
Is one with Nineveh and Tyre.”
continued Rudyard Kipling’s Recessional (1897) after the title’s line. That sentiment was hugely premature for the British Empire of 1897, brought down only by two idiotic world wars. It is however far more pertinent for the world as a whole today, as the countries where economic freedom is possible dwindle in number towards the null point, with only Argentina going the other way, possibly briefly. But why?
The U.S. midterm elections were a disappointment, but they should not have been. No progress has been made in tightening elections’ security and many states still conduct their elections on electronic voting machines, which a moment’s thought will tell you are fatally easy for bad actors to subvert, to any extent needed. The refusal of a Republican Senate, under the leadership of the feeble and duplicitous John Thune (R.-SD) to carry even the most elementary election security legislation when they had the opportunity, suggests that this problem will only get worse. Oregon has used mail-in ballots since 2003; no Republican has won a state-wide election since then, in a state that used to return two Republican Senators (Mark Hatfield and Bob Packwood). The possibilities of electoral fraud are thus infinite and permanent.
That potential was well illustrated in Brazil, which uses machines universally, by Lula’s unexpected electoral victories in 2022 and 2026. When you look at the results state by state, it is obvious that dirty work has been carried out. The big cities, which you would expect to trend left, showed solid but not overwhelming figures for the Bolsonaro family. Conversely, most rural areas, especially in the impoverished northeast, showed gigantic majorities for the leftist Lula, quite unlike the voting pattern in any other country. The exceptions to this anomaly were a few rural provinces, which showed substantial majorities for Bolsonaro, as you would expect from international voting patterns, where rural areas almost universally trend right. Furthermore, the votes cast in Lula-voting states were extraordinary – from them you would expect Recife (population 3.7 million) to be larger than São Paolo (population 11.9 million). When analyzed carefully, the fraud is obvious and vitiates any attempt to claim Brazil as a democracy.
Apart from electoral fraud, which appears prevalent (but may be less easy in countries with a broad-based constituency system, such as Britain) there are many factors leading to the decline of the human civilization that has done so well for the world’s living standards. It is incidentally unfair to call it “Western Civilization” – Japan has been contributing substantially to the industrial world’s advances since the 1880s, Southeast Asia followed from the 1970s and India and China have made major material contributions (if damaging in other respects) since 2000.
Part of the problem is the grossly excessive immigration that Western countries have allowed since 1990 – Japan has so far been much more sensible in this respect. By making their welfare systems available to such immigrants, Western governments have provided a grotesque incentive for the idler and more disruptive inhabitants of the Third World — to achieve a standard of living as good as available at home without work, and with the chance of political activism that is emotionally satisfying, even if wholly destructive to the host nation. President Trump has temporarily put a stop to this in the United States, but even he is showing signs of weakening. There can be no doubt that if a Democrat is elected President in 2028, the flood of welfare-drawing riff-raff will recommence, if only because they are reliable votes for every Democrat Islamo-Marxist with dreams of glory.
However, even excessive immigration is a less important producer of a Recessional than excessive budget deficits and government spending. This is already at a critical level in the United States and several European countries such as France; the recent Democrat midterm victory in the U.S. will unquestionably worsen it. The U.S. appropriations process has been irretrievably broken since the Democrat post-Watergate “reforms” of the 1970s. Today, even with a favorable majority in the House and Senate, the Federal budget, produced with great care by the Office of Management and Budget as a result of well-designed 1920s reforms, is treated with utter contempt by Congress, either being ignored altogether or, if the Speaker is Nancy Pelosi, torn up. The various Committees of Congress then get together and add in all their favorite boondoggles, after which the result goes to the Senate and further boondoggles are added by further committees, none of which have any significant commitment to matching income and expenditure.
Most years, the final result is then abandoned altogether in favor of a “Continuing Resolution” which adds further items of expenditure while ignoring the economies that had been made to pay for them. As a result of this process, the U.S. is still operating on the expenditure levels of the Biden Administration’s 2024 Budget, as modified by Congress, so almost none of the 2025 DOGE reforms have been put into effect and excrescences of corruption and leftist waste such as USAID are still being funded. With Social Security due to reach bankruptcy in 2032, the U.S. is close to hitting the fiscal wall at which it can no longer borrow; Britain and several European countries are in the same predicament.
Even more dangerous than the fiscal wall for the well-being of the Western populace, however, is the tsunami of regulation, especially on the “climate change” topic, issued by the EU, Britain and under Democratic administrations, the United States. It has now been shown that the vast majority of “climate change” academic papers have been either fraudulent or just plain wrong – not surprising given the enormous financial and career incentives provided for scientists and economists to produce them. Nevertheless, those papers have been used by leftist agitators, of whom Greta Thunberg is the shining intellectual light, to impose regulations that have the effect of destroying the regulated economy, eliminating per capita economic growth for a decade or more, as in Britain.
Without seeing any benefits of capitalism, and with the supposedly superior effects of “socialism” (actually closer to Eastern European Communism, because of its disdain for free speech and democracy) dinned into them by the monolithic socialist media and education institutions, it is not surprising that today’s young turn away from career advancement and towards nihilist destruction. Certainly, with antiregime speech prohibited and jail sentences imposed, it is vanishingly unlikely that new well-disposed leaders of any strength will arise. If they did, in most countries electoral fraud would be used to block them. Non-profit entities, funded by mad billionaire divorcees like MacKenzie Scott (formerly Bezos) rewarded by the lottery of Western divorce courts, make the chances of success still worse, because they fund the Left’s destruction.
As for intellectual advances, forget them. Australia, for example, is imposing draconian fines on foreign media and AI companies that leak disfavored messages to its citizens. Presumably an “Iron Firewall” against such contamination will follow. Maybe Australia will attempt to create its own AI, trained only on Australian content – in which case its users will be subjected to an AI that is of somewhat below average intelligence, calls everybody “mate,” staggers around drunkenly, and applies sandpaper to its data centers whenever a problem comes up that it cannot deal with.
With infinite low-quality immigration, spiraling debt and budget deficits, growth stymied by excessive regulation and a theological devotion to “net zero” the great majority of nominally democratic societies are doomed to accelerating decline, as Britain suffered after “Recessional” was written in 1897. Only the United States may have the power of self-redemption, if it elects a sound non-RINO Republican in 2028, with adequate Congressional support. Given the lack of election reform, however, that currently looks unlikely. British civilization ended in 1990, though it took some time for this to become obvious; the U.S. may follow Nineveh and Tyre in 2029.
-0-
(The Bear’s Lair is a weekly column that is intended to appear each Monday, an appropriately gloomy day of the week. Its rationale is that the proportion of “sell” recommendations put out by Wall Street houses remains far below that of “buy” recommendations. Accordingly, investors have an excess of positive information and very little negative information. The column thus takes the ursine view of life and the market, in the hope that it may be usefully different from what investors see elsewhere.)